top of page

Identify the Errors in the Yellow Signal Light Equation

Writer's picture: Brian CeccarelliBrian Ceccarelli

They are the reason why drivers run red lights. This equation computes the duration of yellow lights and all-red clearance intervals. Can you identify the errors? Those who have taken an introductory physics class find the first error within 20 seconds. There are over 5 mistakes. Post a comment when you see an error.


Note that t = 1.0s and a = 10 ft/s2 are for the 50th percentile passenger sedan driver driving on dry pavement.


This equation appears on FHWA website and in DOT traffic signal manuals throughout the world:



For an explanation and history of this equation, watch the webinar hosted by the National Society of Professional Engineers (Professional Engineer in North Carolina chapter):


The Yellow Change Interval -- Physics in Opposition https://youtu.be/uqZNdvkSfQ4?si=7Bwd8lGpY2U2yiBW



Analyses of red-light camera data empircally demonstrates that these errors cause over 90% of red-light running.


Imagine the legal liability.


The equation is unlawful under engineering practice law.


 


 
 
 

Comments

Rated 0 out of 5 stars.
No ratings yet

Add a rating
bottom of page